Case File 001 — Now Available on Etsy

Murder by Pieces — Truth is never whole. You star in the story.

You pick the cast. You upload their photos. We turn your friend group into a murder mystery — and ship the whole crime to your door, in pieces.

scroll ↓
Buy Episode 1 on Etsy Notify me about Episode 2

Watch how it works

Thirty seconds. Everything explained.

A quick look at the case, the cast, and how it lands at your door.

— A silent look. Sound coming in v2 —

Nobody else makes this

You're not solving the mystery.
You're in it.

Other murder mystery games hand you a script and a fictional cast. We use your friends. Your faces. Your in-laws. Your family group chat. The killer is someone whose voice you'd recognize at a dinner table — because they were sitting at one with you last week.

How it works

From your group chat
to a sealed crime scene.

Four steps. Three weeks. One unforgettable night.

01

Pick your cast

Choose six people from your life — friends, family, partner, in-laws. Five become suspects. One becomes the body.

Don't know who to cast as the killer?

Tell us a little about each person and we'll cast roles that make sense for the friend group.

02

Upload their photos

Send us a clear photo of each person. We render each one into the noir style of the case — gilded-oval frame and all — and place them in the puzzle.

What if my photo isn't great?

Phone snaps work. We don't send portrait previews — that would spoil the surprise — but if we ever need a clearer photo, we'll reach out before we start.

03

We craft the murder

A custom case file. Six suspect statements. A motive grid. A coroner's report. A wax-sealed envelope with the killer's name.

Gifting it? Will the recipient see spoilers?

Never. The puzzle ships with a neutral cover sticker so the artwork stays a surprise until it's solved.

04

Delivered, in pieces

In about three weeks, your sealed Case File arrives. Break the wax. Assemble the puzzle. Name the killer. Open the envelope.

Need it for a specific date?

Tell us at checkout. We'll prioritize and ship to land before your dinner.

Made by hand

It's not the puzzle that's premium.
It's the conspiracy around it.

i.

Noir, not a filter

Each face is rendered into 1940s noir style — gilded oval, shadowed eyes, the works — then painted into the scene. None of those sad photo-on-a-puzzle gifts.

ii.

A real bound Case File

Suspect statements, motive grids, evidence cards, a coroner's report, a wax-sealed envelope with the killer's name. Hand-bound, not stapled.

iii.

Endlessly replayable

Same friend group, different killer next time. Each new Case File reshuffles the cast — the night never plays the same way twice.

Why not something else

No other "murder mystery game" does what we do.

A quick honest look at the alternatives — and where ours sits.

  Murder by Pieces Hunt A Killer Photo puzzle Murder mystery party kit
Your friends & family as the cast ✓ — photo only —
Custom noir portraits of your cast ✓ — — —
Physical jigsaw puzzle ✓ — ✓ —
Bound case file with evidence ✓ ✓ — printed sheets
Wax-sealed delivery ✓ — — —
One-time gift, not a subscription ✓ — ✓ ✓
Same cast, new killer in every case ✓ new box — —

The cast — sample case

Six portraits. Five alibis. One body.

This is the demo cast for Case File 001 — a Knives-Out-meets-Christie 1940s dinner party. In your version, every face here will be someone you know.

Denny — the photo you'd send us Denny — the painted noir suspect The Photo The Suspect

Denny

The Victim

Anita — the photo you'd send us Anita — the painted noir suspect The Photo The Suspect

Anita

The Sister-in-Law

Dennis — the photo you'd send us Dennis — the painted noir suspect The Photo The Suspect

Dennis

The Rival

Trisden — the photo you'd send us Trisden — the painted noir suspect The Photo The Suspect

Trisden

The Nephew

Kyden — the photo you'd send us Kyden — the painted noir suspect The Photo The Suspect

Kyden

The Protégé

Brayden — the photo you'd send us Brayden — the painted noir suspect The Photo The Suspect

Brayden

The Friend

— Tap or hover any face to see the photo we started with —

“One of these five did it. The puzzle, the case file, and twenty pages of suspect statements will tell you which.”

Hand-cut puzzle pieces — delivered in pieces, sealed until solved

What arrives at your door

A sealed Case File. 110 pieces. One body to find.

  • i

    A premium 110-piece puzzle

    Featuring the full crime scene — every suspect at the table, every clue in plain sight. Beginner-friendly difficulty designed for a one-night solve.

  • ii

    A bound Case File

    Six suspect statements, a motive grid, an evidence inventory, a coroner's report — and a sealed envelope.

  • iii

    Six noir-style portraits

    Your cast rendered into the period style of the case, framed in gilded ovals. Suitable for keeping. Some customers have framed them.

  • iv

    A wax-sealed verdict envelope

    Don't open it until you're sure. We're not responsible for what happens at the table when you do.

The Case Library

A new case every season.

Each release is a different story, era, and aesthetic. The same friend group can buy multiple cases — and the killer changes every time.

Sealed
Case File 001 — The Dinner Party

Case File 001

The Dinner Party

London, 1948. A wealthy host gathers their inner circle for an intimate evening — the family they've spent a lifetime quietly outmaneuvering. By morning the host is dead in their own dining room. Brandy on the lips. No forced entry. No clear weapon. You pick the victim. You pick the five suspects. Every one of them has reason — and the first thing they all agree on is what to tell the inspector.

Difficulty · Best for first-time detectives
Coming Soon
Case File 002 — The Midnight Express

Case File 002

The Midnight Express

January 1928. The Wagons-Lits flagship climbs the Vardar Pass when an avalanche brings it to a dead stop in the snow. Telegraph lines down. Track crew thirty-six hours away. By dawn the most powerful passenger on the train is found strangled in their locked compartment. You pick the victim. You pick the five suspects. Six passengers. Four crew. One sealed train. Everyone has an alibi. Only one of them survives an honest reading of the night.

Difficulty · Bring a stopwatch
Coming Soon
Case File 003 — Ravenmoor

Case File 003

Ravenmoor

Yorkshire moors, 1888. A storm rolls in. The telegraph wire goes down. The ford floods at the carriage road. Inside a granite Jacobean manor, the host gathers their circle for a midnight séance with a celebrated young medium. By dawn the host is found at the writing desk in a study locked from the inside — and there's a half-burned confession in the fireplace, written in the alphabet of witches. You pick the victim. You pick the five suspects.

Difficulty · Bring a candle

Perfect for

A gift that makes everyone at the table reconsider their friendships.

It's a one-of-a-kind gift — nobody else is getting one like this. And it makes the whole room the entertainment.

i.

Milestone birthdays

30th, 40th, 50th — the kind of birthday gift people remember (and won't shut up about for years).

ii.

Anniversaries

Cast your partner as the victim. Cast their family as suspects. Watch the dynamic.

iii.

Friend-group game nights

The dinner party gift you'll be dining out on. Literally. Bring it to the next group hang.

iv.

Family reunions

Cast the entire extended family. Make Aunt Linda the prime suspect. Address the elephant in the room with style.

v.

Holiday gifting

For the family that already has everything. Christmas, Hanukkah, Father's Day, Mother's Day — every gift list, top three.

vi.

Bachelor & bachelorette

Cast the wedding party. Make the in-laws-to-be suspects. Funniest pre-wedding gift the bride or groom will ever open.

“The first one I made was about my own family. They opened the case file and saw each other cast as suspects — eyes lit up immediately. But the real moment came when they started assembling the puzzle. ‘I think those are my eyes.’ ‘Wait — is that my brother?’ Watching them piece their own faces together from puzzle pieces — that mad dash to recognize themselves in the scene — was a sight I'll never forget. So I started making them for other people.”

— Dennis, maker

Five hand-painted noir puzzle-piece portraits arranged on dark wood with one piece missing

There's one piece missing.

The cast is never
complete without you.

Five suspects. One body. And a sixth piece that doesn't exist yet — because we haven't met your people. Send us their photos and we'll paint them in. Then you'll find out which one of them did it.

Questions

Things people ask before they buy.

Because the puzzle is the mystery. The clues are hidden in the artwork — who's where, what's on the table, what's in their hand. If you saw the assembled image online, you'd be solving half the case before the box even arrives. We protect the surprise on purpose.
You upload six photos and a few notes about the people in them. We render each face into the noir style of the chosen Case File, place them in the puzzle and the case file, and write a custom mystery in which one of them is the killer. The whole production is a few weeks, start to finish.
The kit is designed around six cast members and plays best with four to eight people at a table — a dinner party group, a family gathering, a friend group game night. The puzzle itself is satisfying solo too, if you'd rather solve it before hosting.
Adults. Episode 1 is a 110-piece puzzle paired with a text-rich case file (suspect statements, evidence, motive grids). Best for ages 16+. We're working on a kid-friendly companion line — get on the waitlist to hear about it first.
You'll choose from our themed Case Files. Case File 001 is 1940s noir; Case File 002 is 1928 Orient Express art deco. New cases are released seasonally, each with its own setting and aesthetic.
Case File 001 is live on Etsy now. Order takes 2–3 weeks to produce and ship because every cast is hand-crafted. Case File 002 lands later this year — waitlist members get a launch-day email and 20% off.
Episode 1 is $44.99 on Etsy for the 110-piece edition. Premium positioning to match the craft — we'll never undercut what we put into it.
Yes — and we love that. Each case reshuffles who's the victim and who's the killer, so the same group can buy multiple cases and have a totally different night every time.